ISLAMABAD: Pakistan is dismantling a 17-year-old experiment that merged sales and income tax collection into a single administrative structure, after officials concluded the arrangement allowed the sales tax revenue shortfall to balloon to 3.4 trillion rupees ($12.2 billion).
Senior tax officials, speaking to Dawn newspaper on Saturday, said the government will separate functional responsibilities within the Inland Revenue Service, including collection and legal work, to fix weaknesses that fueled the gap.
Under the plan, the administrative structure at the chief commissioner level stays intact for now. Separation starts at the commissioner level and filters down to subordinate officers, with some officials dedicated solely to sales tax. A new member for sales tax and federal excise duty will report directly to the FBR chairman, backed by three chiefs and their teams to maintain sustained focus through data analysis, operations and case follow-ups.
Separate sales tax zones will be created under each chief commissioner, led by commissioners with additional deputy and assistant commissioners. The overhaul begins at Large Taxpayer Offices on Dec. 1, then moves to Corporate Tax Offices and Regional Tax Offices, with completion targeted within two months. Chief commissioners and the IRS operations member keep administrative and operational control, while the new member handles technical oversight and enforcement coordination. Both taxes remain within the IRS rather than split into separate services.
The FBR has already started specialized testing to find officers with the right expertise. “We have already launched an exercise to identify competent officers,” an official said, noting the assessments will match officers to functions suited to their skills.
Internal FBR estimates show sales tax makes up nearly 55% of the combined 6.2 trillion rupee ($22.3 billion) revenue gap, with about 90% of collections coming from just 15,000 taxpayers. Roughly 313,000 people were registered for sales tax in early 2024, but only 190,000 filed returns, many reporting no taxable transactions. By contrast, about 6 million filers actively file income tax returns.
Officials said the merged structure diluted accountability, since officers could hit combined targets by focusing on income tax while neglecting sales tax enforcement. A recent proficiency test in Karachi underscored the imbalance, with officers scoring better on practical income tax matters than sales tax administration.
Production monitoring has shown what targeted enforcement can achieve. In 12 manufacturing sectors with monitoring systems, the revenue gap fell by 12 percentage points of potential collections over two years, while it rose by nine percentage points in seven sectors without such systems. Specialized officers will now use that data to pursue underreported sales, questionable input tax claims and other compliance failures.
The 2009 transfer of sales tax and federal excise administration from Customs to the IRS was part of a World Bank project. Integration was justified because the two taxes are closely linked โ findings in a sales tax case often generate income tax demands โ and separating them risked breaking that link. But after 17 years, official data showed large gaps in both taxes: 3.4 trillion rupees for sales tax and 2 trillion rupees ($7.2 billion) for income tax. Officials said the case for integration had also weakened with the arrival of a common digital system run by Pakistan Revenue Automation Ltd.





